Free Ebook Elizabeth and Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, by JANE DUNN
The Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN has the tendency to be wonderful reading book that is understandable. This is why this book Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN comes to be a favorite book to review. Why don't you want turned into one of them? You can enjoy reviewing Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN while doing various other tasks. The existence of the soft data of this book Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN is kind of getting experience conveniently. It includes how you should conserve guide Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN, not in racks obviously. You may save it in your computer tool as well as device.
Elizabeth and Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, by JANE DUNN
Free Ebook Elizabeth and Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, by JANE DUNN
Book lovers, when you require a brand-new book to read, discover the book Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN here. Never stress not to discover just what you need. Is the Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN your required book currently? That's true; you are truly a great viewers. This is a perfect book Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN that comes from great author to share with you. The book Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN offers the best experience and lesson to take, not just take, however likewise learn.
As known, journey and also experience about lesson, home entertainment, and also knowledge can be acquired by only reviewing a book Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN Also it is not directly done, you can understand even more concerning this life, concerning the world. We provide you this proper as well as easy way to acquire those all. We provide Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN and also lots of book collections from fictions to science at all. Among them is this Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN that can be your partner.
Exactly what should you assume more? Time to obtain this Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN It is easy then. You could only sit as well as remain in your location to get this book Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN Why? It is online book store that give a lot of collections of the referred books. So, just with web link, you could delight in downloading this book Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN and also numbers of publications that are looked for now. By seeing the web link web page download that we have actually offered, guide Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN that you refer a lot can be discovered. Simply conserve the requested publication downloaded and install and afterwards you can enjoy guide to review every single time as well as location you desire.
It is extremely simple to review the book Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN in soft data in your device or computer system. Once again, why need to be so difficult to get guide Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN if you can select the easier one? This web site will alleviate you to pick as well as select the best cumulative publications from one of the most ideal seller to the released publication just recently. It will certainly consistently update the compilations time to time. So, connect to internet and also visit this website consistently to get the brand-new publication everyday. Now, this Elizabeth And Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, By JANE DUNN is all yours.
This is a joint biography of Elizabeth I and Mary Queen of Scots, their reigns and relationship with each other. These rival queens, both with a claim to the English throne, embodied opposing characteristics, ideals of womanliness and divinely-ordained kingship, resulting in a relationship that is punctuated by murder and psychological and actual warfare. Jane Dunn marks the 400th centenary of Elizabeth's death, by chronicling the intrigues of the lives of the rival "sister queens". Dunn juxtaposes the histories of the two women and the power struggle that continued between them until Elizabeth asserted her authority and, albeit hesitantly, signed Mary's death warrant.
- Sales Rank: #9491512 in Books
- Published on: 2003-01-01
- Original language: English
- Binding: Paperback
Review
'Dunn writes with captivating elegance and piercing intelligence, is tender, scrupulous, ironic and worldly.' Richard Davenport-Hines, Independent 'Jane Dunn is one of our best biographers.' Miranda Seymour, Sunday Times 'Jane Dunn has that sine qua non of the true biographer, an eye for significant detail and the power to fit it into a larger pattern.' Richard Holmes, The Times 'Jane Dunn is a gifted biographer, teasing out subtle meanings and connections that add up to a rich depth of portraiture.' Michelle Roberts, Independent on Sunday
About the Author
Jane Dunn was born in South Africa and came to England aged seven. After university, she worked at Vogue before becoming a freelance journalist. She is the author of the biographies of Virginia Woolf and Vanessa Bell, Mary Shelley and most recently a sensational biography of Antonia White. She lives in Bath.
Most helpful customer reviews
89 of 94 people found the following review helpful.
A fascinating side-by-side comparison of two rival queens.
By Monika
Many have criticized this dual biography for not introducing new material, and simply re-hashing what has been written elsewhere. And clearly there is no shortage of excellent biogaphies on both of these queens. However, it is the format of Dunn's book that sets it apart and gives us an innovative perspective. Queen Elizabeth I of England and Mary, Queen of Scots, were both fascinating monarchs in their own right, but equally fascinating is the complex relationship between them. Both women had a claim to the throne of England. Elizabeth was the daughter of King Henry VIII and his second wife, Anne Boleyn. Elizabeth's grandfather, Henry VII, who overthrew Richard III and founded the Tudor dynasty, was also the great-grandfather of Mary (born to King James V of Scotland and Mary of Guise). Elizabeth was Mary's elder by only nine years. Both women were ambitious, passionate, and cunning. Yet despite their similar status as queens and cousins, these two women were also very different from one another.
Mary became Queen of Scotland only six days after her birth in 1542, upon the death of her father. In 1548 she was sent to France, to grow up in the court of her French fiance, the dauphin Francis. Her status was never in question, and therefore she never questioned it herself. Elizabeth, however, traversed a much more tumultuous path to her throne. When her mother was beheaded so Henry VIII could marry his third wife, the young princess was declared illegitimate and removed from the succession. Ultimately her place in the succession was reinstated, but this in no way guaranteed that she would ever become queen. First in line was her radically Protestant half-brother, Edward, who died young. Next came the devoutly Catholic Mary I ("Bloody Mary"), Elizabeth's half-sister from Henry VIII's first marriage, under whom Elizabeth even spent some time in the Tower of London. It was only upon Mary's death in 1558, when Elizabeth was 24 years of age, that she finally ascended the throne herself.
The relationship between Elizabeth and Mary was very multi-faceted (despite the fact that the two queens never met). For most of her life, Mary referred to Elizabeth as a dear sister, and actively sought her cousin's favor. Yet at the same time Mary coveted the English crown, and even on several occasions declared that she herself was the rightful Queen of England. Yet the Queen of Scots, by dint of her as-yet unthreatened sovereignty, could also be presumtuous to a fault. Her impulsive marriage to Lord Darnley, her second husband (who was shortly thereafter murdered), against the will and advice of many in both Scotland and England, marked the beginning of her ultimate downward slide. Elizabeth, while she displayed more pragmatism in matters of the heart, was also somewhat jealous of her cousin's romantic exploits. Elizabeth had realized early on that she could never marry her personal favorite, Robert Dudley, the Earl of Leicester, and that she must instead declare herself to be married to her country, but this did not erase her longing for romantic fulfilment.
Ultimately Elizabeth was forced to imprison, and eventually execute, her cousin and rival queen. Mary, fleeing from Scottish rebels, thought to run to Elizabeth for refuge and support. But Elizabeth insisted on an investigation into Mary's possible involvement in the murder of Lord Darnley, and therefore detained the Scottish queen in a remote castle. Despite Mary's repeated pleas, she refused an audience with her, fearing the Queen of Scots' reputation for beguiling charm. Mary's imprisonment became all the more serious when she was implicated in a plot to assassinate Elizabeth. The English queen had no desire to execute her cousin, despite pressure from her counselors. Only when irrefutable proof of Mary's involvement was produced did Elizabeth finally sign the death warrant, and even then she was plagued with guilt. In all, Mary spent nearly two decades as Elizabeth's prisoner, and was finally beheaded in 1587, still having never met her cousin and greatest rival.
The basic story is obviously the same. Indeed, I think it would be hard to introduce any new material on the lives of Elizabeth and Mary at this point, when we probably already know all we ever will about them. Yet Dunn's presentation here is fascinating. By placing the two queens side-by-side for comparison and contrast, and focussing on their relationship, we get to see both sides of the story simultaneously. This format emphasizes the inter-connectedness of their lives, and really shows how much each was dependent on the other. In many ways each served as the only person who could truly identify with the other, both being women rulers in a time when females were seen as incapable of effective leadership, and being each other's closest blood relatives (with the exception of Mary's son, James VI & I).
Dunn's writing style, while not the most engaging I have ever read, is nevertheless very accessible. She has clearly done her research, and paints a lovely dual portrait of these two women. I also liked the fact that, when using direct quotes, Dunn gives both the original text with its archaic and unstandardized spellings, and also the same quote written with modern spellings, which makes it easier to read and understand. My only real criticism of the text is that she skims over a few events that are considered "well-known," when the book would have been more balanced and informative if Dunn had written on all events with equal detail. After all, not all her readers will have read extensively on these monarchs before picking up this book. On a positive note, the book is equipped with numerous full-color pictures, including portraits of the queens, their family members, important members of their courts, and even some pictures of embroidery Mary completed while imprisoned in England. Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed this book, learned much from it, and would definitely recommend it.
44 of 46 people found the following review helpful.
A Pair of Queens
By takingadayoff
Some have criticized Jane Dunn's history of Elizabeth I and Mary, Queen of Scots, for not covering any new ground. I find that the parallel biography format makes a new look at an old story well worth while. You may already know the histories of the two queens and their separate lives, but to read about them simultaneously makes vividly clear how intertwined their stories are.
Dunn's style is accurate and entertaining without being over-scholarly. The addition of details that other biographers have omitted is welcome. (She mentions that Elizabeth was nearsighted, for instance.) The narrative flows naturally from one queen to the other without seeming choppy. Just when you are starting to wonder what's going on with the other, the scene changes to keep you up to date.
I was somewhat disappointed with the way Dunn treats the murder of Riccio (spelled Rizzio in some accounts). While she discusses fully the repurcussions of the murder, she glosses over the actual sequence of events in one sentence, since the story "is well-known." I think a popular history such as this is the perfect place to include a full account, both for those who are new to the subject and to re-acquaint the rest of us with a dramatic event.
Dunn, like many biographers, is attached to her subjects. She gives everyone the benefit of a doubt. This is surely the most sympathetic account of Lord Darnley that I have read yet. (Especially on the heels of the recent Alison Weir history of Mary and Darnley.) But she backs up her assertions and conclusions with solid arguments and thorough documentation. And although she says that people still tend to divide themselves into Elizabeth admirers and Mary supporters, she seems to have an equal bias for each queen.
35 of 38 people found the following review helpful.
"This island isn't big enough for the two of us"
By Ashley Megan
First, I would like to review the book itself, and then address some of its critics.
Two of history's most famous queens, one for her unexpected and remarkable greatness, the other for her inexplicably poor judgment and bad luck. But was their famous rivalry inevitable? Was Elizabeth always the popular, talented, dominant one while Mary remained in her shadow? Jane Dunn asks these questions, and I was surprised - and pleased - by some of her answers.
The first part of the book is essentially a point-by-point comparison of the two queens, detailing their very different youths and explaining how they would influence the women in later years. Essentially, Mary had a huge sense of entitlement, was overconfident in her own power and security, and was a much more 'traditional' woman - and Queen - of her day. Elizabeth, whose childhood was punctuated by dramatic changes of fortune, had a much more acute sense of how tenuous her position was, and how much she depended on the good will of her people to maintain power.
Dunn does beat the Mary-as-charming-but-spoiled and Bess-as-brilliant-control-freak comparison into us a bit, but it is a good way of looking at the very different natures of these two women. Her book isn't a full biography of either queen; rather it's a look at the intersection between them - their relationship with each other, their competition, rivalry, and common causes. As such it's a fascinating look at a unique time in European history, the so-called "Age of Queens".
Posterity-wise, Mary got the short end of the stick. History will always remember her as Elizabeth's paler shadow, a major annoyance and minor queen who had no one but herself to blame for her tragic end. Although Dunn does occasionally (perhaps unavoidably) slip into Mary-bashing and Bess-worship, on the whole she does a good job pointing out that that wasn't always the case - and, had a few things gone differently, we would paint a very different portrait of the two cousins. Her Mary and Elizabeth are fully human - flaws, quirks, charms, and all. It's the best way to explain the convoluted relationship between the two, and it provides a lot of useful character insight into all other aspects of these Queens as well. (I do wish Dunn had gone further into the possibility that Mary was bipolar. It's a fascinating hypothesis, and it would explain a lot.)
Mary's end - which also serves as the book's - is too rushed; twenty years are covered in a handful of pages and the account of the execution itself offers nothing new. But until that point, I thoroughly enjoyed this provocative and inspiring portrait of two very different women whom circumstances thrust into such fierce competition.
Now: Some reviewers seem to feel that Dunn was somehow "unfair" to Mary and that her comparison of the two queens is misogynist. I admit to being completely baffled by this point of view. It appears to stem from the argument that somehow Mary was a better "feminist" queen than Elizabeth, I suppose because Elizabeth "betrayed the sisterhood" by having Mary executed.
Further, Dunn's critics seem to argue that Mary was a better "feminine" role model than Elizabeth was, apparently because she ruled through emotion rather than reason. They complain that Elizabeth is too "cold" and "calculating" to be a good example of a female ruler, while waxing rhapsodic about Mary's "mercy" and "gentleness". Let me be blunt: this is the sort of idiotic, feel-good, p.c. claptrap that has set the cause of working women back 50 years. Yes, there is something to be said for women's differing management styles; you will get no argument from me that in today's world, women should not have to emulate uber-masculinity to succeed. But - newsflash! - this was the 16th century. Not only were the roles of men and women completely different - and thus incomparable - than they are today, have you ever actually tried to get anything done with the kind of dithering, vapid leadership exemplified by Mary and her ilk?
Attempting to repaint Dunn's dual biography as some sort of feminist management manifesto does a disservice, both to the author and her subjects. We should admire both Elizabeth and Mary for who they were and what they did, while admitting their flaws and shortcomings. But this is not the 1500s, and trying to appropriate their story to make a point about women today is grossly misrepresentative, self-centered, and intellectually careless. If you want to adopt antiquated delusions about women in the workplace, try reading Forbes online - not "Elizabeth and Mary".
Elizabeth and Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, by JANE DUNN PDF
Elizabeth and Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, by JANE DUNN EPub
Elizabeth and Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, by JANE DUNN Doc
Elizabeth and Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, by JANE DUNN iBooks
Elizabeth and Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, by JANE DUNN rtf
Elizabeth and Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, by JANE DUNN Mobipocket
Elizabeth and Mary : Cousins, Rivals, Queens, by JANE DUNN Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar